TROG 2017 Plan Study Results

March 8, 20177 minute read

The excellent presentation given by the TROG team is posted on the “Learn” tab for the TROG Plan Study. This was presented at the TROG 2017 meeting in Auckland, New Zealand on March 6, 2017.

To supplement that presentation, below are tables summarizing the high performers for this study. The first table shows the Top 10% (overall), across all participants. The subsequent tables are organized by treatment planning system (TPS), and these tables show the Top 10% for that particular TPS *plus* any participant with a plan score of 145.2 or higher. (Note: 145.2 was the upper threshold for plan score for the ProKnow achievement system based on overall population.)

Top 10% Overall

Participant NameParticipant RoleParticipant InstitutionParticipant CountryTPS ModelDelivery Type(s)Energy (MV)Total MUPlan Score
Simon HeinzephysicistKantonsspital St.GallenSwitzerlandEclipseVMAT6FFF10689.64148.33
FriedemannotherKantonsspital St.GallenSwitzerlandEclipseVMAT6FFF16490.49148.29
Derek SizemoredosimetristKalispell Regional Medical CenterUnited StatesEclipseVMAT6FFF10909.06148.06
Anthony MagliaridosimetristVarian Medical SystemsUnited StatesEclipseVMAT6FFF9392.04148.01
Frank Simacdosimetrist21st Century OncologyUnited StatesEclipseIMRT (Dynamic)10FFF21803.28147.93
Anisoara Socoliuc Toquantphysicistvrancea75SwitzerlandEclipseVMAT6FFF12104.03147.86
David LittlejohndosimetristRadiological Technologies UniversityUnited StatesEclipseVMAT10FFF9805.202147.86
Thomas CostantinodosimetristRadiological Technologies UnviversityUnited StatesEclipseVMAT10FFF8884.233147.82
Bruce PhillipsdosimetristSouth Florida Radiation OncologyUnited StatesEclipseVMAT10FFF8152.621147.80
Alex NevelskyphysicistRambam Medical CenterIsraelMonacoVMAT6FFF13463.74147.69
Mikhail DiachenkophysicistJSC MedicinaRussian FederationEclipseVMAT10FFF10587.88147.59
MariaphysicistJSC MedicinaRussian FederationEclipseVMAT10FFF9341.082147.54
Tomas ProchazkaphysicistMasaryk Memorial Cancer InstituteCzech RepublicEclipseVMAT10FFF7504.357147.52
Joshua SamstherapistMater NewcastleAustraliaEclipseVMAT10FFF9101.395147.51
Tamas PoczaphysicistCsolnoky Ferenc KorhazHungaryEclipseVMAT6FFF12458.16147.47

Cyberknife – Top 10% Per TPS AND/OR Plan Score > 145.2

Participant NameParticipant RoleParticipant InstitutionParticipant CountryTPS ModelDelivery Type(s)Energy (MV)Total MUPlan Score
Oliver BlanckphysicistUniversity Medical Center Schleswig-HolsteinGermanyCyberKnifeCyberKnife6145.25

Eclipse – Top 10% Per TPS AND/OR Plan Score > 145.2

Participant NameParticipant RoleParticipant InstitutionParticipant CountryTPS ModelDelivery Type(s)Energy (MV)Total MUPlan Score
Simon HeinzephysicistKantonsspital St.GallenSwitzerlandEclipseVMAT6FFF10689.64148.33
FriedemannotherKantonsspital St.GallenSwitzerlandEclipseVMAT6FFF16490.49148.29
Derek SizemoredosimetristKalispell Regional Medical CenterUnited StatesEclipseVMAT6FFF10909.06148.06
Anthony MagliaridosimetristVarian Medical SystemsUnited StatesEclipseVMAT6FFF9392.04148.01
Frank Simacdosimetrist21st Century OncologyUnited StatesEclipseIMRT (Dynamic)10FFF21803.28147.93
Anisoara Socoliuc Toquantphysicistvrancea75SwitzerlandEclipseVMAT6FFF12104.03147.86
David LittlejohndosimetristRadiological Technologies UniversityUnited StatesEclipseVMAT10FFF9805.202147.86
Thomas CostantinodosimetristRadiological Technologies UnviversityUnited StatesEclipseVMAT10FFF8884.233147.82
Bruce PhillipsdosimetristSouth Florida Radiation OncologyUnited StatesEclipseVMAT10FFF8152.621147.80
Mikhail DiachenkophysicistJSC MedicinaRussian FederationEclipseVMAT10FFF10587.88147.59
MariaphysicistJSC MedicinaRussian FederationEclipseVMAT10FFF9341.082147.54
Tomas ProchazkaphysicistMasaryk Memorial Cancer InstituteCzech RepublicEclipseVMAT10FFF7504.357147.52
Joshua SamstherapistMater NewcastleAustraliaEclipseVMAT10FFF9101.395147.51
Tamas PoczaphysicistCsolnoky Ferenc KorhazHungaryEclipseVMAT6FFF12458.16147.47
Vanessa MagliaridosimetristSt Anthony’s Medical CenterUnited StatesEclipseVMAT6SRS13603.91147.00
Mihai EnedosimetristPacific Cancer Institute of MauiUnited StatesEclipseVMAT6FFF10855.88146.94
toolieotherRoyal North Shore HospitalAustraliaEclipseVMAT610834.65146.89
Martin PavlátdosimetristMasaryk Memorial Cancer Institute, BrnoCzech RepublicEclipseVMAT10FFF8738.361146.85
Jonathan StenbeckphysicistGreenville Health SystemUnited StatesEclipseVMAT10FFF & 6FFF11820.9146.73
George TolekidisdosimetristRUSH University Medical CenterUnited StatesEclipseVMAT6FFF10315.24146.72
LyndaltherapistRadiation Oncology, Lifehouse at RPAAustraliaEclipseVMAT6SRS13641.79146.64
Zuo ZhangdosimetristPhoenixville HospitalUnited StatesEclipseVMAT68594.163146.51
Brais RodriguezphysicistIMQ ZorrotzaurreSpainEclipseVMAT6FFF10496.08146.49
Joakim NilssonphysicistSkånes UniversitetssjukhusSwedenEclipseVMAT10FFF8144.508146.45
Daniel BryanttherapistRBWH CANCER CARE SERVICESAustraliaEclipseVMAT67232.766146.43
Csaba GlavakphysicistUniversity of Kaposvar Health CenterHungaryEclipseVMAT6FFF12743.25146.31
Daniel PapworththerapistGenesisAustraliaEclipseVMAT6FFF7441.117146.27
Clare MonktherapistCalvary Mater NewcastleAustraliaEclipseVMAT6FFF9984.997146.07
Anna KalesnikphysicistMIBSRussian FederationEclipseVMAT10FFF7569.894145.74
Dustin Alex WhittingtondosimetristSelf Regional HealthcareUnited StatesEclipseVMAT67694.678145.69
Peter TreondosimetristRhode island hospitalUnited StatesEclipseVMAT611884.93145.68
Yu-Wen ChangphysicistBellin HealthUnited StatesEclipseVMAT6SRS6882.826145.51
Johanna PricedosimetristKarmanos McLaren FlintCanadaEclipseVMAT10FFF11778.76145.46
Phillip MoloneydosimetristUniversity Hospital Geelong – ALCCAustraliaEclipseVMAT10FFF8775.993145.43
Mattia Di MartinodosimetristUniversity Hospital of ZurichSwitzerlandEclipseVMAT6FFF9552.172145.28
BridgetdosimetristThe Cancer Team at Bellin HealthUnited StatesEclipseVMAT6SRS6949.575145.23

Hi Art – Top 10% Per TPS AND/OR Plan Score > 145.2

Participant NameParticipant RoleParticipant InstitutionParticipant CountryTPS ModelDelivery Type(s)Energy (MV)Total MUPlan Score
Shayne EthertontherapistQueensland HealthAustraliaHi-ArtTomo616.4456146.45

Monaco – Top 10% Per TPS AND/OR Plan Score > 145.2

Participant NameParticipant RoleParticipant InstitutionParticipant CountryTPS ModelDelivery Type(s)Energy (MV)Total MUPlan Score
Alex NevelskyphysicistRambam Medical CenterIsraelMonacoVMAT6FFF13463.74147.69
GeorgephysicistRambam Medical CentreIsraelMonacoVMAT6FFF12253.54144.32
Friedlieb LorenzphysicistSDHBNew ZealandMonacoVMAT6FFF10379.35144.14

Pinnacle – Top 10% Per TPS AND/OR Plan Score > 145.2

Participant NameParticipant RoleParticipant InstitutionParticipant CountryTPS ModelDelivery Type(s)Energy (MV)Total MUPlan Score
Ray DalfsentherapistRAHAustraliaPinnacle3VMAT6FFF9918146.30
Stephen JonesotherQuantum Health GroupAustraliaPinnacle3VMAT7 & 7FFF8788.6145.36

RayStation – Top 10% Per TPS AND/OR Plan Score > 145.2

Participant NameParticipant RoleParticipant InstitutionParticipant CountryTPS ModelDelivery Type(s)Energy (MV)Total MUPlan Score
Hisato NaganophysicianShonan　Fujisawa Tokushukai Hp.JapanRayStationVMAT610064.55146.66
ROLLAND JulienphysicistInstitut Paoli Calmettes – CHICASFranceRayStationVMAT87869.217146.31
Mikel ByrnephysicistROC WahroongaAustraliaRayStationVMAT68309.16145.93
Ryohei YamauchiphysicistSt.luke International HospitalJapanRayStationVMAT10 & 611611.59145.58

True Composite Dose QA Results (High Performers with 2%L/2mm 90% or higher)

Participant NameParticipant InstitutionParticipant CountryTPS ModelDeliveryEnergy (MV)Total MUDose QA Device3% (global)/3 mm/10%3% (global)/2 mm/10%2% (local)/2 mm/20%
Oliver BlanckUniversity Medical Center Schleswig-HolsteinGermanyCyberKnifeRobotic6UnknownOctavius SRS 1000100.0100.0100.0
Zuo ZhangPhoenixville HospitalUnited StatesEclipseVMAT68594ArcCheck100.0100.099.0
Mikhail DiachenkoJSC “Medicina”Russian FederationEclipseVMAT10FFF10588ArcCHECK100.0100.098.8
Brais RodriguezIMQ ZorrotzaurreSpainEclipseVMAT6FFF10496PTW Octavius 4D150099.999.398.4
Vadzim PyshniakMCCCMonacoVMAT10FFF9957Matrixx99.298.697.7
Uta MacholdAuckland City HospitalNew ZealandRayStationVMAT66930ArcCheck99.398.397.3
MariaJSC MedicinaRussian FederationEclipseVMAT10FFF9341ArcCHECK99.699.697.2
DANDPANI EPILITata memorial hospitalIndiaEclipseVMAT69233Matrixx98.198.196.8
Dustin Alex WhittingtonSelf Regional HealthcareUnited StatesEclipseVMAT67695MapCHECK100.099.196.7
Sergey BayankinSverdlovsk Regional Oncology ClinicRussian FederationMonacoVMAT68030Delta4100.0100.096.6
Alex NevelskyRambam Medical CenterIsraelMonacoVMAT6FFF13464Delta498.698.095.6
Romena de ChavezPrincess Alexandra HospitalAustraliaPinnacle3VMAT65328Octavius100.099.495.0
Timothy HancockKantonsspital AarauSwitzerlandEclipseVMAT6FFF1836Delta4100.0100.094.9
Friedlieb LorenzSDHBNew ZealandMonacoVMAT6FFF10379ArcCHECK99.398.194.8
shaomin zhangAbington Jefferson HealthUnited StatesEclipseVMAT107536ArcCheck99.398.393.2
Daniel PapworthGenesisAustraliaEclipseVMAT6FFF7441Gafchromic Film99.899.693.0
Jeffrey HarwoodBarwon HealthAustraliaEclipseVMAT10FFF6009ArcCheck98.997.592.8
Yu-Wen ChangBellin HealthUnited StatesEclipseVMAT6SRS6883Matrixx98.495.092.2
Daniel BryantRBWH CANCER CARE SERVICESAustraliaEclipseVMAT67233ArcCHECK99.197.791.5
John ShakeshaftPrincess Alexandra HospitalAustraliaPinnacle3VMAT6FFF8386Octavius 4D SRS 100098.998.291.4
Jonathan StenbeckGreenville Health SystemUnited StatesEclipseVMAT6FFF, 10FFF11821ArcCHECK99.596.490.0
Pasted Image at 2017 03 09 03 12 Pm 1024
Figure 1. Distribution of Plan Scores (All)
Pasted Image at 2017 03 09 03 13 Pm 1024
Figure 2. Distribution of Plan Scores by TPS
Back to list